01dragonslayer
Iron Killer
Mad Referrer
Jacked Immortal
EG Auction Sniper
VIP Member
Shout Master
Mutated
Fully Loaded
- EG Cash
- 1,113,703
Bret_ContrerasElite Coach
First, I apologize if I left out one of your favorite exercises. Don’t take it personally. I performed these experiments in my garage, and while I have one of the baddest garage gyms in Arizona, I don’t have a lot of machines.
I’m also sorry I couldn’t test more individuals. These experiments are very labor-intensive; in order to measure every exercise on every muscle part using a variety of subjects would be a project of colossal proportions. Just remember this: people are different, but not that different. What’s true for me is probably true for you.
Finally, I’m not going to make any judgments regarding the safety of any exercise. I realize that certain exercises pose greater risks to the joints than others, but every guy has the right to train however the hell he chooses. As lifters, we can choose to assume a lot of risk or little risk since we’re the owners of our bodies.
Oh, one more thing: good form, a natural tempo, and a full range of motion were always used in these experiments.
Now that the pre-flight safety announcement list of warnings is over, let’s get to it. Are you ready to build big lats, thick traps, and bulging biceps?
What You’ve Been Waiting For! The Exercises
Since this is a bodybuilding experiment, I used weight that was light enough to allow me to perform at least five repetitions. The only exception was on the weighted chin and pull up movements; I used loads that represented my 3-rep max. The mean number is on top and the peak number is on bottom.To refresh your memory, researchers typically use mean MVC for their data. It measures average activation throughout the entire repetition. Peak activation is a measurement of the highest point of activation during the repetition.
(For more on this, please read “What Are Mean and Peak Activation?”)
| Exercise | Biceps* | Lat | Mid Trap | Lower Trap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bodyweight TRX Inverted Row | 20.3 33.4 | 51.1 82.6 | 25.3 41.8 | 25.6 43.7 |
| Bodyweight TRX Feet Elevated Inverted Row | 21.2 61.0 | 62.4 124.0 | 24.8 61.4 | 26.2 53.6 |
| 25 lb TRX Feet Elevated Inverted Row | 27.7 100.0 | 54.7 138.0 | 52.2 98.8 | 57.2 101.0 |
| Bodyweight Chin Up | 43.2 100.0 | 80.5 133.0 | 32.2 71.4 | 44.6 101.0 |
| Bodyweight Close Parallel Grip Pull Up | 40.3 90.4 | 82.5 131.0 | 24.2 58.0 | 31.6 69.1 |
| Bodyweight Wide Parallel Grip Pull Up | 38.2 90.2 | 75.6 140.0 | 24.3 62.6 | 32.5 83.8 |
| Bodyweight Wide Pronated Grip Pull Up | 28.0 65.8 | 85.5 151.0 | 27.9 63.3 | 33.4 87.3 |
| 90 lb Chin Up | 107.0 205.0 | 108.0 159.0 | 41.9 80.2 | 58.3 104.0 |
| 70 lb Wide Parallel Grip Pull Up | 109.0 184.0 | 75.3 145.0 | 41.2 79.1 | 50.9 105.0 |
| 45 lb Wide Pronated Grip Pull Up | 65.8 145.0 | 102.0 167.0 | 33.4 77.6 | 41.1 115.0 |
| 315 lb Rack Pull | 7.4 23.8 | 89.4 152.0 | 71.7 114.0 | 47.6 86.1 |
| 405 lb Rack Pull | 6.8 11.8 | 93.1 163.0 | 67.4 131.0 | 50.3 90.9 |
| 185 lb Overhand Grip Bent Over Row | 8.6 25.5 | 68.7 130.0 | 62.2 125.0 | 51.0 110.0 |
| 185 lb Underhand Grip Bent Over Row | 19.1 72.8 | 72.7 134.0 | 58.6 146.0 | 50.6 130.0 |
| 225 lb Overhand Grip Bent Over Row | 18.4 75.7 | 76.8 140.0 | 67.5 146.0 | 52.4 112.0 |
| 225 lb Underhand Grip Bent Over Row | 41.6 132.0 | 78.3 146.0 | 61.9 142.0 | 48.5 116.0 |
| 90 lb Dumbbell Bent Over Row | 14.4 73.6 | 63.0 140.0 | 123.0 226.0 | 99.0 160.0 |
| BW Overhand Grip Feet Elevated Inverted Row | 14.9 100.0 | 48.6 119.0 | 54.5 107.0 | 53.4 103.0 |
| BW Underhand Grip Feet Elevated Inverted Row | 17.3 82.4 | 69.4 158.0 | 38.9 86.7 | 33.3 70.1 |
| 90 lb Dumbbell Chest Supported Row | 28.1 135.0 | 87.4 150.0 | 68.2 134.0 | 59.8 120.0 |
| 12 lb Prone Trap Raise | 18.3 39.0 | 11.0 22.1 | 72.5 238.0 | 72.8 170.0 |
| 25 lb Prone Trap Raise | 33.9 94.1 | 15.9 30.4 | 94.2 186.0 | 81.6 165.0 |
| 50 lb Dumbbell Elbows Out Chest Supported Row | 42.6 78.8 | 24.6 87.8 | 100.0 194.0 | 71.9 180.0 |
| Blue Band Seated Row | 27.5 103.0 | 75.8 128.0 | 53.9 103.0 | 52.9 77.7 |
| 280 lb Underhand Grip Pulldown | 22.3 54.6 | 71.2 129.0 | 22.7 55.0 | 32.6 74.0 |
| 240 lb Wide Grip Pulldown | 16.2 52.9 | 63.5 108.0 | 29.0 56.6 | 38.8 69.5 |
| 240 lb Behind Neck Wide Grip Pulldown | 23.7 74.6 | 67.0 117.0 | 23.6 63.8 | 32.3 85.6 |
| 260 lb Narrow Parallel Grip Pulldown | 22.9 51.4 | 58.7 97.5 | 29.9 62.6 | 42.2 87.4 |
| 80 lb Pullover | 2.1 3.8 | 63.1 106.0 | 20.0 35.0 | 14.7 22.3 |
| 100 lb Straight Arm Pulldown | 2.6 5.3 | 65.1 109.0 | 19.5 39.4 | 21.5 39.8 |
| 120 lb Straight Arm Pulldown | 3.2 9.8 | 73.1 131.0 | 17.1 33.5 | 20.6 37.9 |
| 220 lb Seated Row | 16.0 69.7 | 48.0 115.0 | 29.8 55.0 | 28.7 52.1 |
| 200 lb Wide Grip Seated Row | 24.0 61.9 | 28.6 58.4 | 50.6 116.0 | 40.0 70.1 |
| 120 lb Low Pulley Face Pull | 20.5 66.4 | 15.8 43.3 | 43.3 84.6 | 45.9 79.4 |
| 120 lb Mid Pulley Face Pull | 18.2 77.5 | 20.5 51.4 | 45.8 83.0 | 53.1 97.5 |
| 120 lb High Pulley Face Pull | 10.9 51.5 | 23.6 85.1 | 46.3 82.6 | 54.1 87.9 |
| Band Face Pull | 13.2 28.7 | 14.1 29.6 | 37.0 68.3 | 60.3 109.0 |
| 100 lb One Arm Row | 33.1 85.1 | 77.2 143.0 | 84.3 129.0 | 66.8 139.0 |
| 150 lb Standing Cable One Arm Row | 18.8 52.6 | 72.0 131.0 | 40.3 73.4 | 41.1 77.5 |
| JC Band Row | 10.2 46.3 | 55.0 96.3 | 30.7 73.7 | 35.9 54.5 |
| 60 lb Dumbbell Curl | 52.9 118.0 | 21.0 72.7 | 68.7 161.0 | 43.8 88.8 |
| 95 lb Barbell Curl | 64.9 98.3 | 14.0 23.2 | 50.6 88.3 | 34.2 57.6 |
| 115 lb Barbell Curl | 77.1.0 119.0 | 15.7 46.0 | 62.6 102.0 | 42.5 69.1 |
| 135 lb Barbell Curl | 94.7 138.0 | 17.2 50.9 | 66.8 106.0 | 44.9 69.7 |
| 155 lb Barbell Cheat Curl | 93.9 136.0 | 21.3 53.1 | 73.0 150.0 | 47.9 105.0 |
| 85 lb Reverse Curl | 34.0 77.8 | 12.0 20.0 | 64.6 93.2 | 49.5 65.8 |
| 50 lb Hammer Curl | 47.8 98.1 | 11.8 18.3 | 52.3 109.0 | 37.7 84.5 |
| 60 lb Hammer Curl | 54.9 105.0 | 15.1 22.8 | 55.4 92.4 | 43.0 77.1 |
| 115 lb Easy Bar Curl | 74.7 146.0 | 11.7 19.2 | 72.4 110.0 | 56.1 78.4 |
| 50 lb One Arm Preacher Curl | 80.0 145.0 | 12.5 26.7 | 48.9 95.4 | 37.3 71.9 |
| 50 lb Concentration Curl | 76.1 143.0 | 20.9 54.1 | 47.3 85.6 | 33.9 63.1 |
| 30 lb Dumbbell Incline Curl | 53.6 109.0 | 15.8 34.7 | 26.8 61.1 | 20.6 46.3 |
The Winners
Based on this experiment, here are the top three exercises in terms of mean and peak activity for each muscle part:Biceps
Mean: Weighted Wide Parallel-Grip Pull-up, Weighted Chin-up, Barbell CurlPeak: Weighted Chin-up, Weighted Wide Parallel-Grip Pull-up, EZ-Bar Curl
Lats
Mean: Weighted Chin-up, Weighted Pronated Wide-Grip Pull-up, Rack PullPeak: Weighted Pronated Wide-Grip Pull-up, Rack Pull, Underhand-Grip Feet Elevated Inverted Row
Mid Trap
Mean: Dumbbell Bent-Over Row, Dumbbell Elbows Out Chest-Supported Row, Prone Trap RaisePeak: Prone Trap Raise, Dumbbell Bent-Over Row, Dumbbell Elbows Out Chest-Supported Row
Lower Trap
Mean: Dumbbell Bent-Over Row, Prone Trap Raise, Dumbbell Elbows Out Chest-Supported RowPeak: Dumbbell Elbows Out Chest Supported-Row, Prone Trap Raise, Dumbbell Bent-Over Row
Confirmations
This series of experiments was the most predictable of the ones I’ve performed. Almost all great backs are built by heavy chins, pull-ups, bent-over rows, and deadlifts. We’ve always known that chins and pull-ups hit the biceps hard and that deadlifts and bent-over rows work the entire back. A few years ago, Alwyn Cosgrove recommended training your upper back if you want bigger biceps; judging by the upper back activity involved in heavy barbell curling, it seems that Mr. Cosgrove was right.We’ve long suspected that lat pull-downs are inferior to chinning for lat activation, and now we have some data to support this claim (although the comparisons aren’t really fair as I went heavier on the chins).
Some say that wide-grip pull-ups are better than underhand-grip chins for lat development, but they’re actually very close. The weighted chin-up edges out the weighted pull-up in mean activity, and the weighted pull up-edges out the weighted chin-up in peak activity. Quid pro quo.
I was always a bit skeptical of the prone trap raise and wondered how it stacked up to heavy chin and rowing movements for mid and lower trap activation. I’ve got to hand it to vintage T NATION contributor Don Alessi, who included the prone trap raise in several different programs almost a decade ago, as well as shoulder guru Eric Cressey, for recommending this exercise. It’s a kick-ass isolation exercise for the mid and lower traps.
I’ve never been a big fan of the wide-grip seated row, since the range of motion seemed too short. This experiment lends validity to my hunch. I also thought the dumbbell elbows out chest-supported row was an extremely underutilized exercise for the mid and lower traps. Right again.
Surprises
Biceps isolation movements didn’t top the charts in mean or peak activity! What?! I’ve always recommended biceps isolation movements over triceps isolation movements, but according to my experiments, it may be wiser to isolate the triceps since the biceps appear to get worked thoroughly during compound movements. (Still, I think it’s wise to incorporate some biceps isolation movements.)I was shocked that weighted parallel-grip pull-ups went toe to toe with weighted chin-ups in biceps activity. Both of them landed in the top two spots for mean and peak biceps activity.
I often wondered if the increased range of motion in the dumbbell bent-over row led to increased lat activation over the barbell bent-over row. This experiment cemented my belief. (I used a 45-degree angled hand position on this exercise and raised the dumbbells up a couple of inches higher than I do when I use a barbell.)
The TRX and blast strap feet elevated inverted row didn’t seem to activate as much overall back muscle as the overhand and underhand grip barbell counterparts. Maybe it’s because my torso met the barbell at the upper abdomen, which increased the lever length. In the TRX row, I raised my body closer to the shoulder joint.
I was shocked that some of the movements I love didn’t perform as well as I expected, specifically the dumbbell chest-supported row and the band seated-row (seated rows using a jumpstretch strong band and a v-handle). I really feel these movements working the entire upper back region, but according to this experiment, they’re inferior to other exercises.
What If?
During experiments like these, one is often left with much curiosity. Why didn’t I test corner rows (aka T-bar rows) and power cleans? Why didn’t I make Dan John happy and test the power curl (a combo of the power clean and barbell curl)?Now that the study is over, I’m pissed at myself for not going heavier on rack pulls. I could’ve pulled 405 for 12 reps.
What if I had used a 5RM and increased the load to around 475? Similarly, I can go heavier on one-arm rows. What if I would have used 140 pounds or 160 pounds and “cheated” a bit? How would the common chest-supported row machine have fared in this experiment? What about various row machines and Hammer Strength lat machines?
I could’ve gone much heavier with dumbbell pullovers but it was difficult to get into position without touching the electrodes to the bench (which would have interfered with the readings). I could’ve gone heavier with dumbbell bent-over rows and dumbbell elbows-out chest-supported rows, too.
And perhaps the biggest question: Why the hell didn’t I test the king of all back exercises, the conventional deadlift?
The Best Damn Back and Biceps Workout
Based on the results of this experiment, I bet the following would be one kick-ass workout that’d target the lats, mid, and lower traps as well as the biceps. Enjoy!- Weighted Pull Up, Weighted Chin Up, or Weighted Parallel Grip Pull Up
- Dumbbell Bent Over Row or Weighted Feet Elevated Inverted Row
- Dumbbell Elbows Out Chest Supported Row or Prone Trap Raise
- Deadlift or Rack Pull
- Barbell Curl or EZ-Bar Curl
